IOC, WTA, USTA, RTF and ITF — It Is Time To Call Shamil Tarpischev
To Account For His Comments Against The Williams Sisters.
Tennis is a sport that is played by few but watched by millions. It is often referred to as a gentleman or gentle lady sports partly due to the high level of sportsmanship displayed during matches. This is often observed when players give their victory speeches and acknowledge their losing opponents. Sportsmanship is also evident when tennis players raise their hands to apologize to their opponents when they hit a net cord to get an unintentional winner. In addition, relative to other popular sports, tennis is rarely tainted by scandals such as drugs, violence or illegal betting.
While the general perception of tennis in positive, there is a darker side to the sport, which has emerged in the nearly 20 years since the Williams Sisters came on the scene. Ever since Venus and Serena Williams turned professional, they have been at the receiving end of negative sentiments from the media, fellow tennis players, tennis fans and tennis pundits. Although most people refuse to acknowledge it, many of these attacks are racially motivated.
A few days ago, Shamil Tarpischev, a member of the International Olympic Committee (IOC) and President of the Russian Tennis Federation (RTF) joined the “illustrious” company of tennis legends, tennis commentators, tennis players and tennis fans in taking a stab at the Williams Sisters. It is for this reason that we are writing this letter to you in your capacity as overseers for certain aspects of tennis.
To recap, on 7th October 2014, Shamil Tarpischev along with former tennis player Elena Dementieva was interviewed on the Evening Urgant show (a Russian late night show watched by millions). During the show, Ivan Urgant, the host told Elena Dementieva that he once attended an Olympics Games tennis event. He then stated, “Unfortunately, not those Olympic Games, Lena, where you became an Olympic champion. It was the Olympic Games, where Masha Sharapova played with one of those…….” Before he had finished his comments, Tarpischev interjected saying, “Williams Brothers.” After laughing along with Tarpischev, the host continued, “The Williams brothers. Well, because I cannot bring myself to call them… Look at our female tennis players. They are all slim, elegant and simply the sister passed by me. We were walking under the stand and the sister [laughter] passed by me. I treat these outstanding sportsmen with great respect, but when she was passing by me, her shadow fell on me and this shadow disappeared only after about 40 seconds. [Laughter] They are so powerful.” The host then asked Tarpischev for his view and he replied, “It is scary when you really look at them [Laughter].” (See Appendix A for the link to video and the translated transcript).
Granted that the show’s host comments were distasteful and also granted that Elena Dementieva refused to be drawn into the distasteful joke, however it is unfortunate and disturbing that in a public forum watched by millions of people, a high-ranking tennis director could refer to two of the greatest tennis players of their generation as the “Williams Brother”. Tarpischev should know better, after all he is not only a former tennis player and Davis Cup captain and coach but he is also the President of the Russian Tennis Federation and a member of the International Olympic Committee.
Tarpischev’s reference to the Williams Sisters as men is degrading not only to the Williams Sisters, but also to millions of women of African origin. Tarpischev’s comments about the Williams Sisters anatomy serve a white privileged narrative about the sexualisation of the black woman. When the slave masters, the slave traders, the slave makers and the colonialists first came into contact with the African continent, they had a sickening obsession with the black women and unfortunately, this perverted thinking still persists in the second decade of the twenty first century. Tarpischev’s comments also serve a white privileged narrative about the so-called aggressive nature of the black woman, which is often expressed in phrases like “angry black woman.” Tarpischev’s reference to the Williams Sisters as men also serves a white privileged narrative about the ugliness of the woman of color and what better way to express it than to call them the Williams Brothers.
While we are appalled at Tarpischev’s comments, we are equally appalled by the silence of the tennis establishment. A wise man by the name of Martin Luther King once said, “There comes a time when silence becomes betrayal.” Unfortunately, the tennis aristocracy, the tennis fraternity and the tennis hierarchy time and time again through its wall of silence have betrayed the Williams Sisters. When Billie Jean King set out to fight for women’s rights in tennis in the 60’s and 70’s, she dreamt of a world where female tennis players would be respected both on and off the court; yet today as the Williams Sisters continuously get dehumanized and publicly humiliated, the Women’s Tennis Association (WTA) remains silent.
Year after year, the Williams Sisters continue carry the flag of American tennis. When other American players on both sides of the ladies and men’s draw fall by the way side, Serena and Venus Williams have been the last Americans standing. They have brought pride to America, yet in return for their efforts, the United States Tennis Association (USTA) turns a blind eye as commentators, the media and tennis officials tarnish Serena and Venus legacies. As Richard Williams rightly put it, “We had put a black tennis player on the podium of Olympic victory, but when she came down, she was still just another nigger.” In addition, if the USTA can’t stand up for Serena and Venus when they are dehumanized in their won country, what can one expect to happen when they are debased in another part of the world?
The International Tennis Federation (ITF), which is the governing body of world tennis, has failed to act on a vitriolic comment made by one of the Presidents of its member national association. We don’t need to remind you of the ITF Welfare Policy which applies to Covered Persons such as Shamil Tarpischev. For the sake of clarity, the policy states, “Covered Persons shall not abuse his or her position of authority or control, and shall not attempt to or compromise the psychological, physical or emotional wellbeing of any player.” Surely Tarpischev’s reference to the Williams Sisters as men in a public forum could be construed to be an abuse of position because he was invited to the Urgant show in his capacity as the President of the Russian Tennis Federation and unfortunately he used the platform to compromise the psychological and emotional wellbeing of Venus and Serena. The Russian Tennis Federation also has a responsibility to act. Tarpischev is the president of the RTF so his actions reflect on the Federation.
Since Tarpischev is a member of the International Olympic Committee, it is imperative that the IOC speaks out. According to the Olympic Charter, “The goal of Olympism is to place sport at the service of the harmonious development of humankind, with a view to promoting a peaceful society concerned with the preservation of human dignity.” The charter also stipulates, “Any form of discrimination with regard to a country or a person on grounds of race, religion, politics, gender or otherwise is incompatible with belonging to the Olympic Movement.” In addition one of the missions of the IOC of which Tarpischev is a member, is “to encourage and support the promotion of women in sport at all levels and in all structures with a view to implementing the principle of equality of men and women.” Can we then say that the Olympic movement is preserving human dignity when a key Olympic official ridicules two Olympians on a public forum? To what extent is describing the Williams Sisters as men in aid of the promotion of women in sports?
The IOC cannot and must not maintain a wall of silence because of Venus and Serena Williams’ positive contribution towards the Olympic movement. Venus and Serena are not only Olympians, but they are also elite Olympians. They are the most decorated tennis Olympians with four gold medals each. No other tennis player (male or female) has acquired more Olympic gold medals than the sisters.
It is necessary for the IOC, WTA, USTA, RTF and ITF to act swiftly whenever a high-ranking representative behaves in a manner, which brings the game into disrepute. Failure to do so could be deemed to be a latent approval of the act. It is also time for the quintet of the IOC, WTA, USTA, RTF and ITF to break its deafening silence on the continuous humiliation of the Williams Sisters in the public domain by the media, commentators, high ranking tennis officials, fans, fellow players. While the continuous silence towards the ill treatment of the Williams Sisters might appear to be a more convenient option, in reality it sends a wrong message to those on the other side of the color line. The silence of the tennis hierarchy towards the humiliation of the Williams Sisters signals that tennis is a lily white sports with no place for blacks; the silence of the tennis establishment towards the humiliation of the Williams Sisters signals that that female players are second class citizens who should be viewed only as sex objects denominated in beauty and sexiness rather than respected for their tennis talents; the silence of the tennis aristocracy towards the humiliation of the Williams Sisters signals that the Olympic committee got it wrong by making Serena and Venus compete for medals in the ladies tournament; the silence of the tennis authorities towards the humiliation of the Williams Sisters signals that it is impossible for black females to excel in life through their own ability; the silence of the tennis regulators towards the humiliation of the Williams Sisters signals that black women are ugly; the silence of the tennis elite towards the humiliation of the Williams Sisters signals that racism is welcome in tennis.
We therefore call on the IOC, WTA, USTA, RTF and ITF to break its wall of silence and speak out. We call on the tennis hierarchy to investigate Tarpischev’s comments about the Williams sisters and if you believe like us that he has humiliated Serena and Venus; if you believe like us that he has brought the game to disrepute; if you believe like us that black women as a whole have been ridiculed – you should put pressure on him to apologize to Venus and Serena publicly. In the event that he refuses to apologize, then pressure should be put on him to do the honorable thing and resign his position as President of the RTF and committee member of the IOC.
We also call on the IOC, WTA, USTA, RTF and ITF to take a stand against racism in tennis. There should be zero tolerance towards racism. The tennis world can no longer deny that racism is none existence in tennis. The tennis world can take a cue from the football world by putting structures in place to address racism. We implore you to develop a comprehensive anti-racism policy. The anti-racism policy could specify what constitutes unacceptable behaviour and players and officials that breach the rules should be punished. We urge you to consider setting up racial awareness campaigns to educate fans on the need to be racially tolerant. It is clear for all to see that more black girls have started playing tennis due to the “Williams Sisters” effect, so it is important that the tennis authorities prevent these upcoming players from going through what Venus and Serena have had to endure for almost 20 years.
Over the last twenty years the Williams Sisters have changed the game of tennis. They have acted as positive role models and drawn millions of people to tennis. The have encouraged a new generation of black people to take up the game. Inspite of this, to rephrase Winston Churchill, never in the history of tennis has someone been hated by so many and loved by so few.
Selah.
Ahmed Sule, CFA
For and on behalf of Alatenumo Inc
October 2014
CC:
Thomas Bach – IOC
Nawal El Moutawakel – IOC
Craig Reedie – IOC
John Coates – IOC
Zaiqing Yu – IOC
Stacey Allaster- WTA
Laurence Applebaum- WTA
Matthew Cenedella – WTA
Leah Rinfret- WTA
Francesco Ricci Bitti – ITF
Juan Margets – ITF
Jean Gachassin – ITF
David Haggerty -ITF
Stephen Healy –ITF
Lazarev Alexandrovich – RTF
Selivanenko Evgenievich – RTF
Bokarev Removich – RTF
David A. Haggert – USTA
Katrina Adams – USTA
Tommy Ho – USTA
Gordon Smith- USTA